Episodes 01

“Persons of Interest”

Charles, Oliver, and Mabel are arrested and interviewed by Detective Williams and Detective Kreps before being released due to lack of evidence. Mabel suggests they follow the police’s advice and stay away from the case. Later, a woman named Alice invites Mabel to an art show at a local gallery and encourages her to pursue art again. Oliver runs into Amy Schumer as she moves into Sting’s apartment; she wants to turn the podcast into a TV series. Meanwhile, Charles is approached to play “Uncle Brazzos” in a Brazzos reboot. The trio discovers that Cinda has started a podcast on the three of them, encouraging them to investigate to clear their names. Mabel reveals Bunny said “14” to her before she died. The trio breaks into Bunny’s apartment and discovers her pet parrot mimicking Bunny. When Howard and Uma walk in, the three hide and overhear them panic over a painting missing from Bunny’s apartment. Sneaking through a back elevator, they return to their apartments, and Charles discovers the missing painting on his wall.

Episodes 02

“Framed”

Charles realizes one of the people in the painting is his father, while Mabel reveals Bunny also said “Savage” to her before she died. At Howard’s invitation, the trio attends a memorial for Bunny, planning to return the painting to Bunny’s apartment. There, they meet Leonora Folger, Bunny’s mother and the owner of the painting. Oliver and Mabel sneak the painting up the elevator into Bunny’s apartment, planning to meet Charles outside by the elevator, but Charles accidentally lets the door close, locking them out. In a panic, they stash the painting near a dumpster but later find it missing. Mabel returns to the art studio, where Alice encourages her to smash art to release her emotions, and they eventually kiss. Oliver meets with Amy in her apartment and discovers that she found the painting by the dumpster and hung it on her wall. Leonora talks to Charles about the painting, causing him to remember a day from his childhood when his father was arrested. Leonora learns the painting is at Amy’s but upon inspection, declares it is a fake. Bunny’s parrot is delivered to Oliver as per Bunny’s will, and the bird says “I know who did it.”

Episodes 03

“The Last Day of Bunny Folger”

The trio tries to find out what Bunny’s last day was like before she died. In a flashback, it is revealed that on Bunny’s last day as board president she considered moving to Florida after her retirement. She received a phone call from a mysterious person who wanted to buy her painting, but she rejected it. She also gave present money to her regular café server, Ivan, and easily fixed the elevator when she, Charles, and Mabel got stuck in it. At the end of the day, she realized how much the Arconia meant to her and decided not to retire, upsetting her successor, Nina Lin, who openly threatened her to step down. Later, Bunny visited Charles, Oliver, and Mabel, offering a bottle of champagne in hopes of joining their celebration, but they thought she was just stopping by and did not invite her in. A masked and gloved figure attacked her when she returned to her apartment. The trio feels guilty that they could have saved Bunny’s life “with a simple act of kindness.” They realize Nina had enough motive to kill Bunny, making her the prime suspect in the investigation.

Episodes 04

“Here’s Looking at You”

Lucy, the teenage daughter of Charles’ ex-girlfriend, unexpectedly shows up at his apartment. She reveals to Charles, Oliver, and Mabel that there are secret tunnels inside the walls of the Arconia that she discovered years earlier. As they walk through the tunnels, they overhear Nina and her husband agreeing that Bunny had to go so that the Arconia could be modernized. Oliver also witnesses an argument between Teddy and Theo Dimas, who have been released on parole, which makes Oliver reevaluate his relationship with his son. Later, the trio and Lucy visit Nina to get her to confess to Bunny’s murder, but she goes into labor and asks them to find Bunny’s killer. Lucy confesses to Charles that she ran away from home after her mother remarried. Though touched by Lucy’s words that he is the best stepfather she ever had, Charles insists she go home. Before leaving, Lucy warns Charles that he is in danger, but she does not tell him that she came to the Arconia on the night of Bunny’s murder and saw the killer escaping through the tunnels. Charles visits Jan in prison to ask for her help.

Episodes 05

“The Tell”

Jan tells Charles that the killer is possibly an artist since they composed the crime scene to frame Mabel. Charles and Oliver learn that Mabel is dating Alice, who is an artist, and they become suspicious of her. At a party Alice hosts for an eclectic art crowd, Oliver proposes a murder game called “Son of Sam.” By the end of the game, he declares Alice the murderer and asks a multitude of probing questions, forcing her to reveal that she lied about her background and her studies so people would think she is a legitimate artist. Later, they learn that Bunny had met someone in her regular diner the day before she died, and the person might be the killer. Alice apologizes to Mabel for lying to her, and the two reconcile by sharing personal secrets. Meanwhile, Will takes a DNA test for his son’s school project, which reveals that he has Greek ancestors despite Oliver’s Irish heritage. Oliver sadly speculates that his ex-wife may have had an affair with Teddy, who might be Will’s biological father.

Episodes 06

“Performance Review”

The trio wants to ask Detective Williams’ help with a fingerprinted matchbook they recently found, but she is on maternity leave. When they receive a text message in her name to leave their evidence in a public place, they fear that this is the killer trying to get their hands on the evidence. They decide to leave a glitter bomb instead to catch the killer, but their personal problems distract them during the waiting until they miss their opportunity. Meanwhile, Cinda finds a man from Mabel’s past who falsely claims that Mabel cut off one of his fingers, and she wants to use this in her podcast. Cinda’s assistant, Poppy, has second thoughts about it, and reveals some hidden truths about Cinda to Mabel. Mabel later goes to Alice’s art studio where she finds Alice recreating the crime scene of Bunny’s murder for an art exhibit. Heartbroken, Mabel runs off, but sees a glitter-bombed person in her subway car. Later, Charles and Oliver see an Internet video of Mabel seemingly stabbing that person.

Episodes 07

“Flipping the Pieces”

A series of flashbacks details Mabel’s relationship with her father before his death from cancer. Following the subway incident, Mabel wakes up in Theo’s apartment with no memory of the attack and her bag missing. Theo explains to her that he was in the subway car too, saw what happened, and brought Mabel home after she passed out. He shows Mabel an employee badge from Coney Island that her assailant had dropped, so they go there to investigate. Mabel recovers her bag before her assailant discovers her, but finds the matchbook gone. Meanwhile, Detective Williams visits Charles and Oliver, who reveal that they have the murder knife, which they give her for analysis. After fleeing Coney Island, Mabel forgives Theo for Zoe’s death and remembers the night of Bunny’s murder, realizing she saw someone escaping from her apartment. Reuniting with Charles and Oliver, Mabel shows Charles a picture of Lucy that she found in her bag. Fearing Lucy is the killer’s next target, Charles tries to call her, but the call is cut off when a blackout hits the city.

Episodes 08

“Hello, Darkness”

Knowing that Lucy is alone in Charles’ apartment, the trio races back to the Arconia to save her from the killer. Meanwhile, the blackout forces the Arconia’s residents to make new connections. Howard hangs out with one of his neighbors, whom he has a crush on, and eventually asks him out, despite the man’s lethal allergy to cats. Concurrently, Lester, the doorman, helps Nina assemble a baby swing, during which Nina evaluates Lester’s job and gives him a promotion. The trio discover that someone broke into Charles’ apartment and chased Lucy through the secret tunnels. They later encounter Marv in the tunnels, believing he is the killer, but in reality Marv wanted to help the trio catch the killer yet unintentionally scared them away with his presence. At Marv’s request, Oliver agrees to record him for a podcast episode while Lucy finally tells Charles what she saw on the night of Bunny’s murder. After the power returns, the trio meets Detective Kreps in the building. Mabel notices some glitter on his neck and realizes he was her former assailant.

Episodes 09

“Sparring Partners”

Mabel tries to confront Detective Kreps about his involvement in Bunny’s murder. He denies everything, but mentions his admiration for Cinda’s podcasts, heightening Mabel’s suspicion. Meanwhile, Charles and Oliver discover the original Rose Cooper painting hidden under the cage of Bunny’s parrot. Charles further discovers that Leonora is Rose Cooper herself. She reveals to Charles that she and his father were lovers for years and he was arrested as a result of trying to defend her from her enraged husband. She also shows Charles another painting hidden in the canvas, picturing young Charles and his father. Elsewhere, Oliver learns that Teddy is indeed Will’s biological father, but, for Will’s sake, they both decide to keep this a secret. Alice gives Mabel a jigsaw puzzle as a peace offering, and with the help of that, Mabel realizes one of Cinda’s podcasts mentioned a restaurant with the logo she saw on Kreps’ backpack. When she questions Poppy about this, she reveals herself as Becky Butler, the subject of the podcast, and that Kreps is Cinda’s lover who helped Cinda provide evidence. Mabel concludes that Cinda is the true mastermind behind Bunny’s murder.

Episodes 10

“I Know Who Did It”

The trio stages a killer reveal party where they endeavor to induce Bunny’s killer into confessing. After failing with Cinda, Mabel declares Alice the killer, which seems to be true when Alice stabs Charles in the stomach. Cinda praises Mabel for solving the case, which makes Becky so frustrated she unwittingly reveals information only the killer would know. As Charles wakes up unharmed, all the guests reveal the entire party was an act to expose Becky as the real killer. Detective Williams found out the murder knife had Becky’s DNA on it and Mabel realized Bunny said “14 Sandwich” to her, which was Becky’s favorite meal at Bunny’s regular diner. Becky is arrested along with Kreps, who is revealed to be Becky’s lover and accomplice. Their motive was to become famous by “solving” the murder and making their own podcast about it. With the case closed, Charles gets a proper role in the Brazzos reboot and asks out his makeup artist, Joy; Mabel and Alice resume their relationship; and Oliver reconciles with his son, who already knows they are not biologically related. One year later, on the opening night of a Broadway play Oliver directed, the lead actor, Ben Glenroy, suddenly collapses on stage during his performance.